First Posted: 2/22/2013
PITTSBURGH — Suspended state Supreme Court Justice Joan Orie Melvin and the sister who worked for her were convicted Thursday of corruption for allegedly misusing state-paid staffers to do campaign work.
The sisters were each convicted of six counts for the work done on Melvin’s 2003 and 2009 Supreme Court campaigns. Jurors were unable to decide one count of official oppression against Melvin, 56, who was accused of firing her Superior Court law clerk-turned-key witness, Lisa Sasinoski, after she objected to doing political work in 2003.
The sisters were each found guilty of several counts of theft of services, as well as criminal conspiracy, and one count each of misappropriation of state property.
Janine Orie, 58, also was convicted of evidence tampering for ordering a Superior Court staffer to delete political files from court computers once the Allegheny County district attorney began investigating in late 2009.
One of Melvin’s conspiracy convictions stemmed from cover-up activity, too: a three-way call between herself, a third sister, former state Sen. Jane Orie, and Orie’s former chief of staff Jamie Pavlot. During the call, Melvin and Jane Orie allegedly told Pavlot to remove any political documents from a file Pavlot took home after they learned of the investigation.
Janine Orie’s attorney, James DePasquale, said of the verdict, I didn’t like it, I’ll tell you that.
Melvin and Janine Orie, who followed her sister as a Supreme Court aide, remain suspended without pay and the Judicial Conduct Board has disciplinary charges pending against Melvin.
Art Heinz, spokesman for the Administrative Office of Pennsylvania Courts, said the conviction doesn’t immediately change Melvin’s status, though the Court of Judicial Discipline has the authority to remove her from office if the Judicial Conduct Board charges are proven. Heinz wasn’t sure if the Supreme Court, itself, could remove Melvin from office and said Chief Justice Ronald Castille was not immediately commenting.
Pennsylvania Bar Association President Thomas Wilkinson said the verdict represents a sad chapter in the history of Pennsylvania’s justice system and bolsters the association’s position that justices should be appointed, not elected. Wilkinson was hoping the court – which has been split with 3 Republican and 3 Democrat justices since Melvin, the Republican swing vote, has been suspended – will soon have a seventh justice.
The staunchly Republican, conservative Catholic sisters from Pittsburgh’s North Hills suburbs have argued the charges were overblown or outright lies whipped up by Democratic Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen Zappala Jr., allegedly because the Ories have opposed the expansion of legalized gambling, an industry in which Zappala’s relatives have an interest.